LCA2010 Wednesday Keynote
Another must-grab-the-video talk : Mako‘s keynote. Antifeatures, principles vs pragmatism do come together. The principled side – RMS & the FSF – important to control ones technology because its important to control ones life. The pragmatic side – quality, no vendor lock etc. False dichotomy.. freedom imparts pragmatic benefits even though it doesn’t intrinsically import quality, good design: 95% of projects 5 contributors; median number of contributors 1, and such small collaborations are no different than a closed source one.
Definition of antifeatures – built functionality to make a product do something one does not want it to do. Great example of phone books: spammers pay for access to the lists, and thus we have to pay *not to be listed*, but its actually harder to list and print our numbers in the first place. Mako makes a lovely analogy to the mafia there. Similarly with Sony charging 50 dollars not to install trialware on windows laptops in the past.
Cameras: Canon cameras disabled RAW saving…. CHDK, an open source addon for the camera outputs RAW again. Panasonic are locking down their cameras to reject third party batteries.
The tivo is an example of how focusing on licensing can miss the big picture: free stack, but still locked into a subscription to get an ongoing revenue stream.
Dongles! Mako claimed there wasn’t a facebook appreciation group for dongles… there is.
Github: paying for the billing model – lots of code there to figure out how many projects in a repo, so that they can charge on that basis.
DRM is the ‘mother of all antifeatures’ – 10K people writing DRM code that no users want!
Filed under: Uncategorized | Leave a Comment